How Far Ahead to Order a Custom Cake

By Sugar Tits ·

Short answer: as early as you can, and never less than three days. Long answer: it depends on what you are ordering, when you need it and how extra you want it to be. Everything we make is baked fresh to order in London, so here is how to plan your order without the last-minute panic.

The rule: three days' notice, minimum

We need at least three days' notice on all orders. That is the bare minimum for us to bake, decorate and pack your treats properly, and it applies to everything from a box of Glitter Bomb Brownies to a single letter cake. Three days works well for treats straight from the shop with no changes. The moment you want something personalised, add more time.

A rough guide by type of order

These are our suggestions rather than hard rules, but they are what makes life easiest for everyone:

What you are orderingSuggested noticeWhy
Treats from the shop, as they areAt least 3 daysOur minimum. Baked fresh, packed, ready for collection or courier.
Loaded letter or number cakesAbout a week, more for weekendsEach one is decorated by hand and we confirm your letters and colours with you first.
Bespoke designs and personalised treatsTwo to three weeksTime to chat through the design, agree colours and get everything just right.
Branded treats for launches and press daysAs early as possibleLogos, brand colours and printed details all need signing off before we start.
Weddings and big eventsAs soon as you have a datePopular dates go first, and bigger orders need more planning.

In a rush? Ask anyway. If we can make it work, we will.

Why custom cakes need more time

The design conversation

A bespoke cake starts with a chat: your theme, your colours, your inspo pictures, any names or slogans. Then we come back to you to confirm. That back-and-forth is quick by email but it still takes a day or two, especially if the birthday girl keeps changing her mind about the shade of pink.

Handmade decorations

A lot of what makes our cakes look the way they do is handmade: candy, chocolate pieces, sparkly bits and toppers. Some of it needs time to set before it can go anywhere near a cake.

Special ingredients

Gluten-free and vegan sponges, a particular colour of chocolate or a specific drizzle might need sourcing. The earlier we know, the easier it is to make sure we have it.

The calendar

There are only so many cakes we can make well in a day. Weekends fill up first, and some weeks of the year fill up fast.

Dates to book early

If your celebration falls on or near one of these, give us extra notice:

  • Christmas and New Year, when everyone wants a showstopper at once.
  • Valentine's Day (and Galentine's).
  • Mother's Day, which in the UK falls in spring.
  • Easter, when our Easter treats compete with your custom orders.
  • Halloween and bonfire weekend.
  • Summer weekends, which are packed with weddings, birthdays, baby showers and garden parties.
  • Graduation season and end-of-term parties.
Box of pink Candy Land cupcakes topped with rainbows, sweets and chocolate pieces
Candy Land cupcakes: one of the treats that needs only our three-day minimum.

What to send us when you get in touch

The quickest way to a confirmed order is to give us everything in one go. Before you get in touch, have these ready:

  1. The date and roughly what time you need your order.
  2. Collection or courier. Collection is from Sugar Tits HQ, or you can add courier delivery within London at checkout.
  3. How many people you are feeding, or how many treats you want.
  4. Flavours and dietary needs, including allergies, gluten-free or vegan requests.
  5. Your colour theme and any inspiration pictures.
  6. Words: letters, numbers, names or sassy slogans, spelled exactly as you want them. Stuck for ideas? See our letter cake ideas.
  7. A rough budget, so we can suggest what works best for it.

Collection, couriers and the post

Some of our treats are city girls. Loaded letter cakes and brownies travel within London only, by courier or collection, and cannot be posted. Macarons can often be posted, though some of the fancier ones may not survive the trip, so check with us first. Lollipops can be posted, even internationally. If you are planning a party outside London, factor that in early.

Can you order too early?

You can never book too early, but freshness matters. We bake to order, so even if you book months ahead, your treats are made just before your date. Brownies are at their squishiest on the day, for example, and will keep for up to four days in an airtight container. Lollipops are the exception: stored somewhere cool and dry, they keep for months, which makes them a great early buy for party favours.

Allergies and special requests

Tell us about allergies at the very start, not the day before. Our product pages list allergen information, and some of our decorations may contain gelatine, so they are not always suitable for vegetarians. Our kitchen handles nuts and other allergens, so there is always a chance of cross-contamination, and we will be honest with you about what we can and cannot do.

The takeaway

Three days is the minimum. A week is comfortable for a letter cake. Two to three weeks is ideal for anything bespoke. Weddings, events and big brand moments: the second you have a date. Browse our cakes for inspiration, then holla at us and let's get your date in the diary.

Keep reading